All the Clues ‘Summer House’ Couple Kyle and Amanda Were Headed for Divorce

Signs Kyle and Amanda’s Marriage Was on the Rocks

Fans of the hit reality show Summer House have long speculated about the future of Kyle Cooke and Amanda Batula’s relationship. Married in 2021, the couple surprised many when they announced their decision to part ways amicably in early 2026. But looking back, there were numerous clues hinting that their marriage was facing serious challenges well before the official announcement.

In January 2026, Kyle and Amanda shared a heartfelt joint statement on Instagram: “After much reflection, we have mutually and amicably decided to part ways as a couple. We share this with a heavy heart and kindly ask for your grace and support while we focus on our personal growth and healing.” This message marked the end of a relationship that had once seemed strong but was quietly unraveling behind the scenes.

Amanda’s Career Shift at Loverboy

One of the earliest indicators that things were not perfect between Kyle and Amanda came nearly two years before their breakup announcement. Amanda stepped back from her role as creative and branding director at Loverboy, the beverage company founded by Kyle. Previously, Amanda had paused her own career in 2019 to dedicate herself full-time to Loverboy, but by 2024, she admitted to Us Weekly that she had taken a “slight step back for the sake of our relationship.”

Amanda explained the tension that arose from their intertwined professional and personal lives. “I think that we were at a place where I would be frustrated about something happening on my end, and he would take it very personally,” she said. “Or he’d complain about something that I approved, and I made a decision on, and I would take it personally. So it wasn’t great for our relationship.” This admission revealed the strain their working relationship placed on their marriage, foreshadowing deeper issues to come.

Working Through Relationship Challenges

Despite the difficulties, Kyle and Amanda were open about their efforts to work through problems. In November 2024, they told Us Weekly that their relationship had “tough” moments. Kyle acknowledged, “There’s a lot under the rug,” admitting he didn’t always handle situations well. Amanda shared that they had sought therapy and worked on themselves, noting how watching their interactions on television was “very eye-opening.”

“We’ve learned a lot and have grown from it,” Amanda said. “We’re still working on it.” This transparency gave fans hope that the couple might overcome their struggles, but it also highlighted the ongoing challenges they faced behind closed doors.

Rumors and Reality: Facing a Rough Patch

Rumors swirled in late 2025 that Kyle and Amanda were living apart, though they denied these claims multiple times. However, a source told Us Weekly in November 2025 that the couple was going through a “challenging time” but remained committed to making their relationship work. Their appearance at BravoCon 2025 showed a united front, although they notably did not walk the red carpet together, signaling underlying tension.

Around this time, Kyle teased a new spinoff series, Summer House: In the City, which would follow their lives in Manhattan. He described the show as an honest look at their day-to-day experiences, including business and friendships, and promised viewers a glimpse into their evolving relationship dynamics.

Marital Issues Highlighted in Season 10 Trailer

The first trailer for Summer House Season 10, released in December 2025, made it clear that Kyle and Amanda’s marital problems were front and center. Kyle confronted Amanda about their “compatibility, chemistry, intimacy,” bluntly stating, “What about that s***?” Meanwhile, Amanda accused Kyle of frequently staying out late due to his career, even claiming he once fell asleep at a fan’s house after a show, returning home at 6:30 a.m.

Kyle later clarified the situation in a statement to People magazine, denying that he slept at a fan’s apartment but admitting he fell asleep on a couch after an event that Amanda chose not to attend. “Do I regret the situation? Absolutely,” he said. Amanda responded cryptically to viral footage of Kyle partying, indicating that the night in question wasn’t the one she had referenced.

Family and Future Plans: A Growing Divide

Another significant source of tension was their differing views on family planning. Amanda openly discussed wanting children on her timeline, while Kyle appeared hesitant and unprepared. In April 2024, Amanda joked about having to “trick him into getting me pregnant,” highlighting his reluctance to commit to fatherhood.

During Season 9, Amanda expressed frustration that Kyle wasn’t ready to become a dad, saying, “I’m ready to have kids with someone who’s ready to have kids with me.” She later told Us Weekly that Kyle needed to be on her page regarding starting a family, especially given her past health and fertility challenges. Amanda also revealed that conversations about having children were happening more with others than between the two of them, underscoring a disconnect in their communication.

Conclusion: What Fans Can Learn from Kyle and Amanda’s Journey

The story of Kyle Cooke and Amanda Batula’s marriage on Summer House is a poignant reminder that even couples who appear perfect on screen can face real struggles behind the scenes. From career pressures and communication breakdowns to differing life goals, their journey highlights the complexities of maintaining a relationship under the public eye.

If you’re a fan of Summer House or interested in relationship dynamics, keep following their story for more insights. And if you’re navigating your own relationship challenges, consider seeking support and open communication as key steps toward growth.

For more updates on your favorite reality stars and relationship advice, subscribe to our newsletter and stay connected!