All the Clues ‘Summer House’ Couple Kyle and Amanda Were Headed for Divorce

Signs Kyle and Amanda from ‘Summer House’ Were Heading Toward Divorce

Fans of the hit reality show Summer House have long speculated about the state of Kyle Cooke and Amanda Batula’s marriage. The couple, who tied the knot in 2021, shocked many when they announced their decision to divorce in early 2026. Their joint statement expressed a mutual and amicable parting, but the clues were there for those paying close attention. Let’s explore the key indicators that Kyle and Amanda’s relationship was on shaky ground well before their official announcement.

Amanda’s Career Shift at Loverboy

One of the earliest signs that the couple was experiencing tension came nearly two years before their split when Amanda stepped back from her role at Loverboy, the beverage company founded by Kyle. Amanda had been the creative and branding director, but in 2024, she revealed she took a step back “for the sake of our relationship.” She explained that disagreements about business decisions often became personal, creating friction between them. This career adjustment hinted at underlying challenges in balancing their professional and personal lives.

Working Through Relationship Challenges

Kyle and Amanda openly admitted to facing difficulties in their marriage. In a candid interview in late 2024, Kyle acknowledged that he sometimes struggled to handle situations well, while Amanda shared that they had sought therapy to work through their issues. Watching themselves on television also gave them new perspectives on their behavior and communication styles. Despite their efforts to grow and improve, it became clear that their relationship was under significant strain.

Rumors and Reality of Living Apart

Speculation about the couple living separately circulated for months. Although Kyle and Amanda denied these rumors multiple times, insiders later confirmed they were navigating a “challenging time” in late 2025. Even though they appeared together at BravoCon 2025, they did not walk the red carpet as a couple, signaling that their relationship was far from stable.

New Opportunities and Added Pressure

During BravoCon 2025, Kyle teased a new Summer House spinoff called In the City, which would feature both him and Amanda. While this opportunity promised fresh exposure, it also meant more scrutiny and pressure on their relationship. Kyle described the show as an honest look at their lives, including the ups and downs, which may have amplified existing tensions.

Season 10 Trailer Reveals Marital Struggles

The first look at Summer House Season 10, released in December 2025, laid bare the couple’s issues. Kyle openly discussed problems with compatibility, chemistry, and intimacy, while Amanda accused him of frequently staying out late due to his career demands. These revelations painted a picture of a marriage struggling to maintain connection amid growing personal and professional challenges.

Controversy Over Kyle’s Late-Night Activities

Following the trailer’s release, Kyle addressed rumors about spending the night at a fan’s apartment after a show. He clarified that while he did stay out late and fell asleep on a couch at an event, he did not sleep at a fan’s home. Amanda’s cryptic Instagram comment on the viral footage of Kyle partying only added fuel to the fire, suggesting ongoing tension and mistrust.

Holiday Season and Family Planning Disagreements

The 2025 holiday season further highlighted the couple’s distance. Kyle shared family photos without Amanda, prompting fans to notice her absence. More importantly, their differing views on starting a family became a significant source of conflict. Amanda expressed a desire to have children on her timeline, while Kyle appeared hesitant and unprepared for fatherhood. This fundamental disagreement underscored deeper incompatibilities in their future plans.

Communication Gaps and Emotional Disconnect

Amanda revealed that conversations about having children were often happening without her involvement, leaving her feeling sidelined. She also faced personal health and fertility challenges, which added emotional complexity to their situation. The lack of open communication about such an important topic contributed to growing frustration and emotional distance between the two.

Conclusion

The journey of Kyle Cooke and Amanda Batula from Summer House shows how even couples who appear strong on the surface can face serious challenges behind closed doors. From career sacrifices and therapy sessions to late-night controversies and family planning disagreements, the signs were evident that their marriage was struggling. Their decision to part ways was a mutual and thoughtful choice aimed at personal growth and healing.

If you’re a fan of reality TV couples or interested in the dynamics of relationships under the spotlight, stay tuned for more updates on Kyle and Amanda’s post-divorce journeys. Don’t forget to subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news and exclusive insights into your favorite stars’ lives!